top of page
Logo white + red.png


A red electrocardiogram
A red electrocardiogram
A red electrocardiogram

A Comprehensive Guide to Care Reports in Clinical Negligence Cases (By Caroline Cocking RN)

A photo of Jane Collins, Senior Expert at Apex Health Associates

"Caroline is an exceptional expert who delivers what’s needed, on time, to an excellent standard." 

In the UK healthcare and legal system, care reports play a pivotal role in quantifying clinical negligence cases. These reports, prepared by care experts, offer an objective and thorough analysis of a Claimant’s needs and the care provided. In this blog, we explore the basic components of a care report.

What is a Care Report?

A care report is a comprehensive document that evaluates the care needs of a Claimant following an injury such as a clinical negligence event. Essential in both legal and medical contexts, these reports provide an in-depth analysis of the Claimant’s requirements and the associated costs. Care experts are tasked with assessing the Claimant’s situation and compiling a detailed report covering various aspects of care and support needed.

Understanding the Importance of Care Report

Care reports are indispensable tools in clinical negligence cases. They bridge the gap between medical facts and the practical needs of the Claimant. By documenting the extent of the injury, the ongoing care requirements, and the associated costs, these reports provide a clear evidential picture for the Court. This clarity helps in determining fair compensation and ensures that the Claimant's future needs are comprehensively addressed.

Key Components of a Care Report

Nursing, Personal Care, and Domestic Support:

  • This component includes a detailed analysis of the Claimant’s care needs, evaluating the care provided from the date of the clinical negligence to the present, and estimating future care costs. This evaluation often requires a thorough review of medical records, interviews with the Claimant and their family, and sometimes consultations with healthcare providers.

  • The assessment also covers personal care activities like bathing, dressing, and feeding, as well as domestic tasks such as cleaning, cooking, and shopping. These evaluations can reveal significant ongoing needs that must be met to ensure the Claimant's quality of life.

Aids and Equipment:

  • The report details the necessary medical and non-medical equipment required by the Claimant. This includes items such as wheelchairs, special beds, mattresses, hoists, moving devices, showering and bathing facilities, rails, cooking and eating devices/aids, and communication devices. The cost analysis includes capital costs, running costs, and ongoing replacement costs.

  • Care experts also assess the suitability of current equipment and recommend upgrades or additional items to improve the Claimant's independence and comfort.

Transport Costs:

  • An evaluation of the additional transport costs incurred due to the injury. These costs may include specialised transport vehicles, modifications to existing vehicles, and increased usage of taxis or other transport services due to the Claimant's reduced mobility.

  • This component ensures that transportation needs are met, enabling the Claimant to attend medical appointments, participate in rehabilitation, and maintain social connections.

Miscellaneous Extra Costs:

  • This includes costs for heating, gardening, household decorating, and other expenses that arise because of the injury. For instance, a Claimant with reduced mobility may need gardening and cleaning services due to an inability to perform these tasks themselves.

  • These seemingly minor expenses can accumulate, significantly impacting the Claimant’s financial situation.

Home Modifications:

  • A detailed description of necessary modifications to make the Claimant’s home suitable for their needs. This could include installing ramps, widening doorways, adapting bathrooms, and ensuring accessibility throughout the home.

  • In cases of extensive injury, the Claimant may require suitable accommodation to be sourced if their current home cannot be adapted. This might involve significant costs and logistical considerations.

Rehabilitation and Case Management:

  • Recommendations for rehabilitation to help the Claimant achieve maximum recovery and restore independence. This includes physical therapy, occupational therapy, and psychological support.

  • Case management services are also crucial. Case managers coordinate care, provide advocacy, and ensure that all aspects of the Claimant's recovery are addressed. They organise essential services such as care packages, staffing, training, and management, providing a holistic approach to care.

Care Package and Additional Costs:

  • Introduction of a care package that outlines the comprehensive care plan for the Claimant. This includes daily care routines, emergency plans, and contingency measures.

  • Evaluation of extra holiday costs due to the injury and other miscellaneous additional costs. These might include specialised travel arrangements, additional support during vacations, and other unique requirements due to the Claimant's condition.

Loss of Services in Fatal Accident Claims:

  • In cases of fatal accidents/negligence, this component involves the valuation of the loss of services provided by the deceased. This might include childcare, home maintenance, and other contributions that the deceased made to their family and household.

  • Accurate valuation ensures fair compensation for the family, acknowledging the profound impact of the loss.

The Role and Obligations of Care Experts

Care experts play a critical role in clinical negligence cases. Their obligations extend beyond the preparation of care reports and include:

Independence and Objectivity:

  • Care experts must remain independent and impartial, regardless of who instructs them. Their primary duty is to the court, ensuring that their findings and recommendations are unbiased and based solely on the evidence.

Thorough Assessments:

  • Conducting detailed assessments of the Claimant’s needs is a fundamental obligation. This involves visiting the Claimant’s home, interviewing the Claimant and their family, reviewing medical records, and consulting with healthcare providers if necessary.

Detailed and Accurate Reporting:

  • Care experts are responsible for compiling comprehensive and precise care reports. These reports must cover all aspects of the Claimant’s care needs, from immediate requirements to long-term considerations, ensuring nothing is overlooked.

Compliance with Legal Standards:

  • Care experts must adhere to legal standards and guidelines, such as CPR Part 35. This includes understanding their duties to the Court, maintaining confidentiality, and ensuring that their reports meet the required legal criteria.

Continuous Professional Development:

  • Keeping up-to-date with the latest developments in healthcare and legal practices is crucial. Care experts must engage in continuous professional development to maintain their expertise and provide the most current and relevant advice.

Follow-up and Ongoing Support:

  • Clinical negligence cases are dynamic, and care experts often need to update their reports as new evidence emerges. They must provide follow-up services, such as answering questions, preparing supplementary reports, and participating in joint discussions.

Providing Evidence in Trials:

  • Care experts may be called upon to give evidence in court. They must be prepared to explain their findings clearly and confidently, supporting their reports with factual and unbiased testimony.

Follow-up Services and Additional Casework

Care experts often update their reports and provide additional casework as needed:

  • Updating reports with new medical evidence or witness statements. This ensures that the care plan remains relevant and accurate as the Claimant’s condition evolves.

  • Answering written questions and preparing addendums or supplementary reports. This helps clarify and expand on the findings in the original report, providing additional insights as needed.

  • Preparing joint discussions and statements. Care experts may collaborate with other experts to provide a unified assessment, facilitating clearer communication and understanding in court.

  • Attending and advising at case conferences and settlement conferences. Their presence ensures that all aspects of the Claimant's care needs are accurately represented and considered during negotiations.

Desk Top Review Service

This service involves advising on a Claimant’s requirements based on available evidence, without the need for a home visit. It is a cost-effective option for preliminary assessments or for cases where a home visit is impractical.

Providing Evidence in Trials

Care experts may be called upon to provide evidence in trials at County Court, High Court, Tribunals, or the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board. Their evidence can be crucial in substantiating the care needs and costs outlined in their reports, influencing the Court's decisions on compensation.

Why Choose Apex Health Associates ?

Apex Health Associates ensures all instructions are undertaken with professional skill, offering value for money through comprehensive care and equipment reports. They handle matters promptly, maintain objectivity and impartiality, and preserve confidentiality. Care experts adhere to their overriding duty to the Court (CPR Part 35.3), maintaining objectivity and independence throughout the process.


Care reports are vital in evaluating and documenting the care needs of Claimants in clinical negligence cases. The involvement of care experts ensures that these reports are thorough, unbiased, and professionally prepared.

Apex Health Associates boasts some of the most experienced and skilled care experts in the field. Our team is dedicated to delivering comprehensive and accurate care reports, tailored to meet the specific needs of each case. With a commitment to professionalism and excellence, Apex Health Associates ensures that every care report is meticulously prepared, providing invaluable support in clinical negligence claims.

By choosing Apex Health Associates, you are not only ensuring a thorough and professional evaluation but also gaining access to a team committed to supporting you through every step of the legal process.



bottom of page